How to Write a Good Performance Appraisal

Muthiah Aulia is a professional SEO specialist and writer with a keen focus on digital marketing. Her writing provides insightful guidance and tailored advice designed to help companies and businesses enhance their digital presence and refine strategies for attracting top talent.

Looking for Elite Digital Talent?
Hire vetted candidates within 2 weeks and save hiring cost up to 70%

Performance appraisals can be a dreaded time for both employees and managers. The process can be draining, uncomfortable, and often leaves one or both parties feeling unsatisfied. But why subject ourselves to this annual "dance"? Let's dive into the reasons and uncover the purpose behind this crucial evaluation.

What Is Performance Appraisal?

performance appraisal

Performance appraisals, aka performance reviews or evaluations, are a crucial evaluation of an employee's contributions and work performance. This yearly assessment provides a platform to measure an employee's skills, gauge their growth and identify their achievements. It's a chance to take stock of progress, set new goals and ensure alignment with the company's vision. Don't just view it as a formality, make the most of it!

Gone are the days of once-a-year performance appraisals. With the fast pace of business today, companies are opting for more frequent check-ins. Quarterly performance evaluations keep employees and managers accountable and on track towards company goals. These reviews provide an opportunity to assess progress, identify challenges and seek out more efficient ways to reach those goals. It's a win-win situation, helping both the individual and the company strive for success.

In a traditional setup, managers take the lead in evaluating employee performance, pinpointing strengths and weaknesses, providing feedback, and setting goals. However, in today's fast-paced, startup culture, performance appraisals are a two-way street. It's a chance for both parties to come together, realign with the company's goals and reinvigorate their efforts. It's not just a formality, it's a collaborative process to drive success for both the individual and the company.

Why Is Performance Appraisal Important?

Performance appraisals are essential in bridging the gap between abstract concepts and tangible results. Sure, weekly and monthly progress reports provide insights, but they don't tell the full story. Performance appraisals dive deeper, exploring the behind-the-scenes work and effort that went into those numbers. It's an opportunity to uncover the true heroes, the unsung contributors, and acknowledge their contributions to the company's success. Quantifying the abstract is crucial in measuring success, driving accountability, and keeping the team motivated.

Performance appraisals offer a unique opportunity to delve into the details and uncover the real stories behind the numbers. Through a thorough one-on-one discussion, managers can gain a deeper understanding of the challenges and triumphs faced by employees. While the main goal of a performance appraisal may be to determine compensation and potential advancement, a well-conducted review can bring even more benefits to the table. From continuous improvement, to increased engagement and overall satisfaction for all parties involved, a performance appraisal is a powerful tool for driving success for the employee, manager, and company alike.

How To Write Performance Appraisal

Maximizing the impact of performance appraisals requires a comprehensive, 360-degree approach. A review that evaluates not just an employee's core job performance, but also their overall contribution to the company and their ability to collaborate with others. It's not just about judging their worth, but also about discovering opportunities for growth and personal development. By embracing a 360-degree approach, the company and manager can provide a supportive environment to help employees continuously grow and improve. It's a win-win for everyone involved.

1. Cover the basics

The HR team is often responsible for crafting the performance appraisal format, but each company has its own unique style and policies dictating how it should be carried out. The key is to ensure the assessment covers all the critical elements of an employee's performance. Here are some core elements that must not be overlooked:

  • Accomplishments
  • Contributions
  • Quality of work
  • Collaboration
  • Commitment
  • Problem-solving skills
  • Strength and weaknesses

Performance appraisals are a dynamic tool, and the list of elements to be assessed can be tailored to fit the specific needs of each company. However, don't skimp on the basics, they form the backbone of a meaningful and effective performance appraisal.

2. Do It Often, Take Notes!

Performance appraisals may only happen annually, but that doesn't mean you should neglect to track employee progress in between evaluations. As a manager, taking notes throughout the year on both positive and negative employee behavior is a must. Whether it's documenting remarkable achievements or areas for improvement, keeping a running record ensures you have a complete picture of the employee's performance when it comes time for the appraisal. So don't wait for the formal assessment to start paying attention, always be ready to jot down key observations.

Don't wait until performance appraisal time to show your employees appreciation! When an employee shines and exceeds expectations, seize the opportunity to shower them with well-deserved recognition. A simple "good job" or a pat on the back can go a long way in keeping employees motivated and engaged. Immediate recognition not only boosts their confidence, but also fosters a positive work environment and cultivates a culture of excellence within your company. So go ahead, give credit where it's due and watch your team soar!

Stay ahead of the curve by regularly monitoring your employees' performance! Don't let underperformance slip under the radar and cause harm to your company's progress. As soon as you notice an employee struggling to meet their goals, take action. Have a one-on-one conversation and offer guidance where needed. By consistently employing this habit in your organization, you can nip potential issues in the bud, and keep your team on track to success. Stay alert, stay proactive, and watch your company thrive!

4. Courageous Candor

Be bold and be honest. Candor is crucial in the performance appraisal process. Don't shy away from giving or receiving critical feedback. Be direct and address any shortcomings head-on. This way, both employee and manager can work together towards finding solutions and driving growth for the company. Candor may be tough, but it's the key to unlocking the full potential of the appraisal process.

Candor can be a tough pill to swallow, but it's the key ingredient to an effective performance appraisal. Don't sugarcoat the truth and miss out on the chance to help your employees grow. Be upfront about their shortcomings and collaborate on finding solutions. With an honest approach, everyone can learn, improve and become the superstars they were meant to be.

Let's be real, nobody is perfect, even the most well-liked, high-achieving employees come with their own set of challenges. But with candor as your tool, you can turn those challenges into opportunities for growth. Take your candid observations and turn them into a roadmap for improvement. Use specific examples from your notes to drive the conversation and set clear expectations for how you want things to be handled in the future. It's a chance for both the manager and employee to come together and work towards a common goal: success.

5. Careful Wording

"Exceeded expectations with a 20% increase in sales", "Consistently exceeded targets with a 95% success rate" or "Demonstrated remarkable improvement in teamwork, resulting in smoother project collaborations." By using quantifiable language, you not only show the employee's progress, but also make it easier to set clear, achievable goals for the future. Make your performance appraisals impactful and memorable, leaving a lasting impression on both the employee and the company:

  • Excels, Demonstrate
    Example: “Ms. So and so excels in her duty as a sales officer as she demonstrates a professional acumen that leads to the company’s sales target.”
  • Manages, Generates
    Example: “Mr. So and so manages to overcome this years’ biggest  challenge and generates more leads year on year by 30%.” 
  • Exhibits, Grasps
    Example: “Mrs. So and so exhibits a remarkable aptitude in her work as the company’s accounting team member with her grasp of the xx method.”

Transform your performance appraisals from dull to dynamic with the right choice of words. Instead of settling for mundane terms like "good", "excellent", or "ok", try action-oriented language like "possesses", "communicates", "monitors", "directs", "achieves", "improves", and many more. These descriptive keywords will bring your notes to life and make your assessment not only clear but compelling too!

6. Clear The Air

End the performance appraisal on a high note! After delving into the details of their performance, wrap up the discussion with a positive and uplifting conclusion. Make sure the employee leaves the meeting feeling motivated and inspired, with a clear understanding of their strengths and areas for improvement. This will foster a more productive and engaged workforce, driving your company's success to new heights.

Wrap up your performance appraisal with a clear and positive vision for the future. Let your employee know exactly what you expect from them moving forward, highlighting what worked well, what needs improvement, and what may need to be discarded. Foster mutual understanding and respect by being clear in both your written and verbal feedback, creating a productive and optimistic outlook for the future.

Transform an awkward and dreaded performance appraisal into a powerful motivator by ending it on a high note! Express your gratitude and offer a clear, achievable plan of action to guide the employee's future success. Provide positive reinforcement and constructive feedback to give them the confidence boost they need to excel.

Final Thoughts

Transform a dreaded yearly task into a positive, uplifting experience by fostering good communication and taking advantage of everyday opportunities to engage with employees. By keeping a keen eye and an open ear, the process of writing performance appraisals can become a breeze, and with a touch of encouragement, both managers and employees can thrive. Don't miss the chance to turn a dreary obligation into a much-needed boost for your team!

Grow your business faster with
Top Tier Remote Talents

Get 300% ROI from your hiring budget