How to Identify, Fix, and Avoid Keyword Cannibalization

Sandy Anugerah is a seasoned B2B writer specializing in work and employee content. Bringing expertise in crafting engaging, industry-relevant pieces that captivate audiences with insightful narratives.

Looking for Elite Digital Talent?
Hire vetted candidates within 2 weeks and save hiring cost up to 70%

Keyword cannibalization is a common issue that many website owners and SEO professionals face. When multiple pages on a website are targeting the same keyword, it can cause confusion for search engines and lead to a decrease in organic rankings. In this article, we will explore five ways to identify and fix keyword cannibalization, ensuring that your website performs at its best in search engine results.

Understanding Keyword Cannibalization

Before we delve into the various methods of identifying and fixing keyword cannibalization, it's essential to have a clear understanding of what it is. Keyword cannibalization occurs when multiple pages on a website compete against each other for the same keyword. This internal competition can confuse search engines, as they struggle to determine which page should rank higher.

What is Keyword Cannibalization?

Keyword cannibalization is the phenomenon where two or more pages on a website target the same keyword. This can happen intentionally or unintentionally, but regardless of the reason, it can negatively impact the website's search engine rankings. It's crucial to identify instances of keyword cannibalization and take appropriate actions to address them.

The Impact of Keyword Cannibalization on SEO

Keyword cannibalization can have several negative effects on the SEO performance of a website. Firstly, it dilutes the overall authority of the website by spreading the ranking potential across multiple pages targeting the same keyword. This can result in lower rankings for all the affected pages.

Secondly, keyword cannibalization can confuse search engines, leading to a decrease in organic rankings. When multiple pages are targeting the same keyword, search engines struggle to determine which page should appear higher in search results, resulting in a loss of visibility and potential organic traffic.

Furthermore, keyword cannibalization can also lead to a poor user experience. Imagine a user searching for a specific keyword and finding multiple pages from the same website in the search results. Instead of finding diverse and relevant information, they are presented with repetitive content. This can frustrate users and discourage them from engaging further with the website.

Moreover, keyword cannibalization can hinder the effectiveness of your internal linking strategy. When multiple pages compete for the same keyword, it becomes challenging to establish a clear hierarchy and structure within your website. This can impact the flow of link equity, making it harder for search engines to understand the importance and relevance of each page.

Lastly, keyword cannibalization can make it difficult for your website to target a wide range of keywords effectively. By having multiple pages targeting the same keyword, you miss out on the opportunity to optimize each page for a unique set of keywords. This limits your website's ability to rank for a diverse range of search queries and attract a broader audience.

Identifying Keyword Cannibalization

Now that we understand the concept and impact of keyword cannibalization, let's explore methods of identifying instances of keyword cannibalization on your website.

Keyword cannibalization can be a tricky issue to tackle, but thankfully, there are several tools available that can help you identify cases of keyword cannibalization. These tools, such as Ahrefs, SEMrush, and Moz, offer features that allow you to input your website's URL and analyze the keywords that different pages are targeting. By examining this data, you can identify any instances of keyword cannibalization and take necessary steps to address them.

But what are the signs that can indicate the presence of keyword cannibalization, aside from using these tools?

1. Drop of Organic Keyword Rank

One common sign of keyword cannibalization is a drop in organic rankings for pages targeting the same keyword. If multiple pages on your website are experiencing a decline in rankings for a particular keyword, it's likely that keyword cannibalization is at play. This occurs when search engines are confused about which page to rank for a specific keyword, resulting in a negative impact on your overall search visibility.

2. Multiple Pages are Receiving Traffic for The Same Keyword

Additionally, if you notice that multiple pages are receiving traffic for the same keyword, it's a strong indication of cannibalization. While it may seem like a good thing to have multiple pages ranking for a high-volume keyword, it can actually dilute the traffic potential and make it difficult for any single page to rank higher in search results. This can lead to missed opportunities for attracting targeted organic traffic.

3. Check the Contents in SERP

Another sign to watch out for is a lack of clear and distinct content focus across your website. If you have multiple pages targeting the same keyword, it can create confusion for both search engines and users. Each page should have a unique purpose and provide valuable, relevant content to your audience. When keyword cannibalization occurs, it can result in duplicate or overlapping content, which can negatively impact your search rankings.

You can verify this by searching in the SERP: site:yourdomain [yourkeyword]. This will reveal whether your content contains similar keywords. It's essential to examine each piece of content to ensure they aren't cannibalizing each other.

By being aware of these signs and utilizing the right tools, you can effectively identify instances of keyword cannibalization on your website. Once identified, you can take the necessary steps to address this issue and optimize your website for better search engine visibility and user experience.

Strategies to Fix Keyword Cannibalization

Now that we have identified instances of keyword cannibalization, it's time to address the issue and fix it. Let's explore three effective strategies to combat keyword cannibalization.

1. Consolidating Similar Content

One of the most effective ways to fix keyword cannibalization is to consolidate similar content. Identify the pages that are targeting the same keyword and determine which page is the most authoritative and relevant. Merge the content from the other pages into the chosen page, making sure to redirect the URLs of the merged pages to the consolidated page. This consolidation helps search engines understand which page should rank higher and reduces competition between pages.

For example, let's say you have a website that sells different types of running shoes. If you have multiple pages targeting the keyword "best running shoes," you can consolidate the content from these pages into a single, comprehensive page. This not only eliminates confusion for search engines but also provides users with a more cohesive and informative experience.

2. Utilizing Canonical Tags

An alternative to consolidating content is to use canonical tags. Canonical tags signal to search engines which page should be considered the original or primary version. By adding canonical tags to the duplicate pages, you can consolidate the ranking potential onto a single page without physically merging the content. This strategy is particularly useful when merging content is not practical or desirable.

For instance, imagine you have an e-commerce website with multiple product pages featuring similar products. Instead of merging the content from these pages, you can use canonical tags to specify which page should be considered the main source of information. This ensures that search engines understand the intended focus and ranking of your pages, reducing the risk of keyword cannibalization.

3. Implementing 301 Redirects

In cases where consolidating content is not an option or when canonical tags are not suitable, you can implement 301 redirects to resolve keyword cannibalization. A 301 redirect permanently redirects one URL to another, indicating to search engines that the original URL has moved to a new, preferred location. By redirecting the URLs of the duplicate pages to the chosen primary page, you can consolidate the ranking potential and ensure that search engines understand which page should be prioritized.

For example, if you have multiple blog posts on your website discussing the same topic, you can implement 301 redirects to redirect the URLs of the duplicate posts to the most comprehensive and authoritative post. This not only helps eliminate keyword cannibalization but also improves the overall user experience by directing visitors to the most relevant and valuable content.

By implementing these strategies, you can effectively address and fix keyword cannibalization on your website. Remember, it's crucial to choose the approach that best suits your specific situation and goals. Whether it's consolidating content, utilizing canonical tags, or implementing 301 redirects, taking action will help optimize your website's visibility and improve its performance in search engine rankings.

Preventing Future Keyword Cannibalization

Once you have resolved existing cases of keyword cannibalization, it's essential to take preventive measures to avoid future occurrences. Let's explore two strategies to prevent keyword cannibalization.

1. Keyword Mapping for SEO

Keyword mapping is a crucial step in preventing keyword cannibalization. It involves creating a comprehensive plan that assigns specific keywords to individual pages on your website. By mapping out your keywords and ensuring that each page targets a unique keyword, you can eliminate the potential for cannibalization.

2. Regular Audits for Keyword Usage

Performing regular audits of your website's keyword usage is another effective way to prevent keyword cannibalization. Regularly review your website's content and make sure that each page is targeting a unique keyword. This approach helps detect any instances of cannibalization early on, allowing you to take immediate action and prevent any negative impact on your SEO performance.

3. Creating Unique and Diverse Content

One of the best ways to avoid keyword cannibalization is to ensure that your website's content is unique and diverse. Each page should offer valuable and distinct information to users, focusing on specific aspects of the topic or keyword. By creating diverse content, you prevent overlap and reduce the likelihood of cannibalization occurring.

4. Understanding the Importance of Content Relevance

Content relevance is another critical factor in avoiding keyword cannibalization. Each page should be tailored to a specific user intent and provide relevant information that aligns with the keyword's search intent. By ensuring that your content is highly relevant, you increase its chances of ranking well without cannibalizing your own keywords.

In conclusion, keyword cannibalization is a common issue that can severely impact the SEO performance of your website. By understanding what keyword cannibalization is, using tools to identify instances of cannibalization, and implementing effective strategies to fix and prevent it, you can ensure that your website's rankings and organic traffic remain strong. Additionally, recognizing the role of content and focusing on unique, diverse, and relevant content creation will further strengthen your SEO efforts and mitigate the risk of keyword cannibalization.

Grow your business faster with
Top Tier Remote Talents

Get 300% ROI from your hiring budget